Currently browsing category

9-5

Short test: 2011 Saab 9-5 Aero

Vehicle: 2011 Saab 9-5 Aero Sedan XWD
Price as tested: CDN$59700

As Saab’s first new car introduction in 8 years, this niche Swedish carmaker has lots on riding on their flagship sedan. Being a flagship, 9-5 needs a proper V6 engine to motivate its size and weight. The Aero is powered by Saab’s turbocharged 2.8 liter DOHC V6 24-valve engine with 300 ponies and 295 lb/ft of torque. Although this powertrain is heavily based on GM’s Ecotec V6 series, its level of refinement is head-and-above those of 6s previously resided in both outgoing 9-5 and 9000. Gone is the previous V6′s roughness during idle and unwilling to rev through the mid and upper range. While the assymetrical turbocharged was a neat concept, it didn’t delivered on what it should be after the peppy low range. The new engine has addressed that aplentry. Saab’s 6-speed manumatic with paddle shifters have worked in rare harmony, once again, huge improvement over the powertrain combination previously resided in V6 Saabs just a couple of years ago.

If there is one issue with 9-5′s dynamics, its the DriveSelect’s Sport setting really have made the ride quality too stiff for most liking especially with the large 19″ wheels on our Aero. While the Sport setting is just too stiff legged even on slightly rough roads, its Comfort mode just made 9-5 way too softly sprung. Unlike Subaru’s Si-Drive and Audi Driver Select, which are able to compromise between ride and all-out handling depending on settings. Saab engineers really have to go back to drawing board to sort out their DriveSelect system before trickle down to upcoming new 9-3 and even 9-2. Perhaps they can learn a few tricks from Porsche’s benchmark Sport Chrono Package.

The interior of 9-5 has been layout decently, generally speaking. Its optional Head-up display tends to wash out while being blurry depending on the sunlight angle. Another problem is Saab still committed to green pointers on the instrumentation gauges, which already looked outdated today. Its completely out of place in a 9-5 which deserve a far classier instrument clusters. As for those Aero seats, its typical Swedish supportive and comfortable. Sadly, the overall shape and the amount of support around the shoulder have nothing on the original 9000 Aero. Its pretty hard to imagine when automotive technology has advanced in the last 2 decades, Saab Aero seats need to take a two steps backward compares to its great forebear.

As nice as the Aero, we still think 2.0 Turbo 4 is the one to bet when its time to consider the 9-5. That’s because its a more balanced package. The standard suspension provides a more supple ride without losing anything, in terms of handling. The DriveSense system doesn’t do anything to improve the handling and ride, instead its making the worse out of its harmonic balance. We think there will be more customers settle for the Turbo 4. While this recommendation is certainly doing no flavor to Saab’s bottom line, it makes more sense from a driver’s perspective.

Likes:
Swedish flair and character
Refined powertrain
Comfortable interior
Large trunk

Dislikes:
Poor compromise when opt for DriveSense
Rough ride with large 19″ wheels
Interior trim quality

Competitions:
Audi A6 3.0T
BMW 535i
Mercedes E350
Infiniti M37

2011 Saab 9-5 Turbo 4

Vehicle: 2011 Saab 9-5 Turbo 4 Premium
Price as tested: CDN$51300

Performance: In just a year ago, many would have thought this car will never seen the lights. Subject to this test drive is Saab’s all-new 9-5.

The new 9-5 is the first Saab that is completely a “Saab” more than “GM Saab” as it uses 70% of their own components while only 30% GM components.

As with a proper Saab, it has to be powered by a forced induction turbocharged engines. The base version is a 2.0 liter DOHC 16-valve 4-cylinder with 220hp and 258 lb/ft of torque. The uplevel Turbo 6 and Aero version comes in a form of 2.8 liter DOHC 24-valve V6 with 300hp and 295 lb/ft of torque. Both with variable valve timing. Given Saab’s expertise on turbocharged 4-cylinder, as it is the 1st car company that innovated this concept a few decades ago. The 220hp 2.0 liter turbocharged is a real deal except for those who are seeking V6 refinement and flexability. As one expects from a Saab turbo, the engine is smooth and willing. Its also completely lack of anything called turbo lag. Mesh the throttle, the 9-5 takes off like a rocket even if it has to carry 4156 lb of Swedish sensibilites. Both the mid and upper range are impressive as in typical Saab turbo fashion. The most astounishing fact is, given 9-5′s porky weight, it still has that low-end acceleration aura whenever you push the throttle. This is the 4-cylinder that has the power with a 6 but return with the fuel economy of a 4-cylinder. In this day and age, when every carmakers are going for small 4-cylinder turbocharged engines from as inexpensive as Chevrolet Cruze to VW Golf GTI hot hatch. Saab was the first company who think this powertrain makes the most senses when it comes to combining performance, fuel economy and efficiency. The 6-speed automatic mates perfectly with this 4-cylinder powertrain, as it combines smooth and coordinated shifting. Given 9-5′s status-in-life, its better to leave the gearbox in “Drive” which provides the best of highway cruising with all those proper ratio gears.

Handling: Although the relationship between GM and Saab are basically dead as we are speaking, the 9-5 was developed during GM era. That explains why it rides on the world-class Global Epsilon platform. The result is a luxury sedan that drive as good as many of the sports sedan out there. The steering provides decent feel and feedback, while returning the same kind of responsiveness and precision one associates with Saab’s sporty character. The Hi-Per stuct front suspension has done a marvelous job on controlling the wheel motions, on the other hand, it allows the rear to slip out a bit for oversteer when going off a corner to make it a bit of a rear-drive feel. The most surprisingly of all is the ride comfort. While the ride is European firm, as one expects from a Saab, its far from being harsh. The ride quality is comfortably compliant while absorbing all the roughness with ease. The understeer is well-controlled, so does 9-5′s ride motion. What is most impressive of all is 9-5′s highway cruising character. Its superb highway stability, mated with those Swedish seats and a well-sorted out suspension provide awesome highway ride all in one package. From a driver’s perspective, 4-cylinder makes more senses than V6 as the front isn’t as heavy. It makes the whole car more balanced to the drive. Even without the DriveSense, 9-5 drives more like a proper sports sedan than a luxury sedan. That has shown how good the suspension calibrations Saab engineers have done.

Brakes: With 4-wheel discs and standard ABS, 9-5′s braking performance is certainly live up to Saab’s promise. The result is there are no brake fades after a couple of harsh stops. The stopping distance is short while pedal always feels crisp and alive. ABS only steps in necessary is an added bonus.

Interior: In terms of luggage space, 9-5 has aplentry. I like the box hinges which won’t crash into anything else beneath. Then add the low liftover, nicely cut-off side sills and proper fold-down rear seats. 9-5 has the ability to haul all of 5 passengers’ weekend gateway with ease.

As for the rest of the interior, it lives up to what we expect from a Saab. And that is for the most parts.

The ones that live up to Saab’s expectations are those awesome seats, which are simply the best in the world when it comes to zooming comfort and support altogether. The instrumentation gauges are clear and analog, while the automatic climate control and stereo are typical Swedish sensibilites without those stupid German knobs.

Unfortunately, the amount of rotten plastic is something we don’t expect from Saab. Especially in their flgaship 9-5 costing over 50 large grand. Back in the good ole’ days, Saab interiors are known for high-quality plastic materials with tasty leather aroma and velour door inserts to add warmth to the cabin. Their cost-cutting measure really have taken away that very aspect on why owing a Saab is so special. While the leather materials are generally of high-quality texture with suppleness, it no longer holds a candle to its rivals. The whole black dashboard looks duff in our tester. Because of all the cost saving, Saab decided to use green pointers which looked outdated a decade ago. They should stick with either red or white pointers with white background. When you consider the fact that a 20 grand Mazda3 has nicer interior quality than a 50 grand 9-5, this is not something acceptable. Its completely unforgivable given Saab’s usual high standards. Shame on you, Saab. :(

However, there is a silver lining behind all those cheap and nasty plastic. Saab’s new owner, Spyker, has promised to bring 9-5′s interior back to the drawing back. They have promised to bring us a far improved interior which is able to justify its price tag. Whether they have enough resources to bring it back, time will tell.

Conclusion: There are two things that come out loud and clear about the new 9-5.
The first thing is new 9-5 is the best Saab ever. As it offers a nice combination of Swedish flair, hallmark turbocharged 4-cylinder performance and driving dynamics worthy of the Saab badge. Another thing is even if 9-5 already 2 generations behind its main rivals for being replaced, its overall merits are good enough to give them a run-for-its-money.

OVERALL VERDICT FOR 2011 Saab 9-5 Turbo 4
=====================================
Performance: 4/5
Handling and ride/fun-to-drive: 4/5
Interior/ergonomics/user-friendliness: 4.5/5
Fit-and-finish/build quality: 3/5
Cargo/accessibility/layout: 4/5
Value-for-money: 4/5

Overall rating: 4/5

Special feature: A farewell to Saab 9-5

All good things have to go. After 12 years and half million units sold, the final 9-5 finally rolled off the assembly line in Trollhattan, Sweden.

When Saab introduced the current 9-5 back in 1997, it was hailed as Sweden’s contender against benchmark mid-size luxury sedans dominated by Germans. Even though its based on previous Opel Vectra, or unremarkable Saturn L-Series, it feels nothing else like those chassis silbings. Instead, it feels every bit as fun-to-drive and Swedish as every Saab does. Anything else from the entry-level 2.0t S to flagship 2.3T Aero with manual gearbox, these are the luxury sports sedan that handle as anything else in its class with comfort to boot.

The 1st facelift bought out “boost control” on Aero with revised trim levels. Instead of calling S, SE and Aero. Saab renamed those Linear, Arc and Aero. It also brought a higher quality interior and better performing powertrains to the party. Saab’s awesome seats remain intact during the revision. The facelifted version is definitely the best Saab and 9-5 ever produced back in those days.

When Audi came out with the current A6 in 2004, BMW came out with current 5-Series in 2003; we were wondering when will Saab bring out its new 9-5. GM’s beancounters decided not to give Saab enough funding to develop a new 9-5, instead, they gave it a poor nose job in 2006. Its not only the styling is ugly, 9-5 is no longer competitive in that segment. Although Volvo’s S80 is one of the worse cars we have ever driven in DirectShift in the last 3 years, it remains a more competitive car than the granddaddy 9-5 which already on the market for over a decade.

The next 9-5 looks to be a very promising entry into the mid-size premium segment, just like its predecessors do. Both 9000 and 9-5 were wonderful cars to begin with, it was just Saab (especially GM) have milk them too long before a complete rehaul. Even at the end of the lifecycle and one very ugly facelift, we still love 97-09 9-5 today. We only hope we will love the next 9-5 even more. :D

2006 Saab 9-5 sedan

Vehicle: 2006 Saab 9-5 sedan automatic with sports and visibility packages
Price as tested: CDN$47180

Performance: The facelifted 9-5 is only powered by one single engine. Gone are the assymetrical turbo V6 and 2.3L light-pressure turbocharged engines in outgoing Linear and Arc. There will be only one trim level with one powerplant to soldier on before the complete replacement arrives. This high-output turbo or what Saab called HOT 2.3L DOHC turbocharged engine is good for 260 ponies and 258 lb/ft of torque. As one would expect from Saab’s legendary turbocharged unit, this one has plenty of bottom end torque due to its maximum torque ranging from 1900 to 4k rpm. The level of refinement is up to usual Saab turbo-4 level given Swede’s expertise of producing excellent small displacement turbo. That’s despite the flexability and NVH have been outgunned by currently the best turbo-4 in the market, VW and Audi’s 2.0T FSI. This HOT has close to no turbo lag with its turbo spools up quickly and swiftly. This engine is either mated with a rubbery 5-speed stick shift or 5-speed manumatic in our tester. The manumatic shifts quite roughly between gears, that’s even with nicely done gear ratios. Both the up and downshifts are very harsh when the driver has the urge to push the car. If you don’t mind the weird clutch take-off and rubbery shifter, take the 5-speed stick.

Handling: Although Saab has claimed they have stiffened up the chassis, 9-5 has started to feel age when the going gets tough. In the past, Aero’s high horsepower feels quite nature in this platform because, back in 2000, this chassis remains quite much better than acceptable. 6 years latter when all the competitions have completely redesigned, this car has got completely outgunned. Other than the chassis flex and torque steer, this car has plenty of understeer and body rolls when pushed. It just doesn’t cut the mustard when it compares to newer competitions. However, steering still feels swift and response. The precision and path traceability remain 9-5′s merits. Saab’s typical substantial Swedish feel remains intact despite the age of the platform. The stiffened up suspension and springs have made 9-5 rides much more poorly on rough pavements, especially on expansion joints. Unfortunately, it doesn’t gain any in the corners.

Brakes: With 4-wheel discs and standard ABS, braking remains exceptional in typical Saab fashion. The brake pedal feels crisp and solid, with ABS kicks in only when necessary.

Interior: Despite 9-5′s age, its interior remains a comfortable place to spend time with. The world’s most comfortable seats are still inside 9-5′s cockpit. Everything is typical 9-5 except for the rather cheap-looking rotary automatic climate control knobs from GM parts pin. The lack of tilt steering is unacceptable in 21st century.

Conclusion: When Saab first introduced the 9-5 back in 1999, it was such an excellent luxury sports sedan that is able to run with heavyweights like Audi A6 and BMW 5-Series. Just when both Audi and BMW already got a new versions of their existing benchmarks, Saab still producing 9-5 using this aging underpinnings. It will be an even tougher sale with such an ugly facelift and questionable interior switchgears, which aren’t feel upmarket at all. Instead of having a new commercial campaign “born from jet”, Saab should start thinking of a reborn of the 9-5. How times have changed in the marketplace in a short 7 years???

OVERALL VERDICT FOR 2006 SAAB 9-5 SEDAN
==================================
Performance: 2/5
Handling and ride/fun-to-drive: 2/5
Interior/ergonomics/user-friendliness: 4/5
Fit-and-finish/build quality: 2.5/5
Cargo/accessibility/layout: 4/5
Value-for-money: 2/5

Overall rating: 2/5

2002 Saab 9-5 2.3t Arc sedan

Short review of 2002 Saab 9-5 2.3t Arc sedan
================================

Based on the best SAAB ever produced, the base engine finally got previous car’s Aero suspension. The Aero suspension provides enough stiffness without sacificing the ride comfort of what an upscale SAAB A6/E-Class/5-Series supposed to be, it also addressed many people’s complaint of base suspension’s floatiness through corners. Along with the user-friendliness and well-furnished interior that is typical of SAAB’s workmanship and ergonomic engineering, superb seats with plenty of leg and headrooms. This package is hard to beat.

Overall rating: 4.5/5

2002 Saab 9-5 Aero sedan

Vehicle: 2002 SAAB 9-5 Aero sedan with 5-speed auto tranny.

Performance: The Aero is powered by a 2.3L high-ouput turbocharged 4-cylinder engine that bumps out 250hp @ 5500 rpm and 258 lb/ft @ 2500 rpm. With impressive numbers like these, power is never an issue. The throttle tip-in is linear. Off-the-line response is brisk. Unlike previous high-pressure SAAB turbos, turbo lag is never an issue. There’s also an impressive feature called “instant-boost” standard on HOT engine series. When you are driving 120 km/h on a freeway ready to overtake a slow vehicle, the system will increase the torque by 12 lb/ft of torque in 20 seconds. Its completely seemless and works exceptionally well. 5-speed auto also works exceptionally well. Both up and downshifts are quick without sacificing the smooth transition. In fact, this is the tyranny that’s good enough to choose it over the rather notchy stick. SAAB should put this box into 9-5 from day 1. In short, 9-5 Aero’s performance is nothing short of amazing.

Handling: Without a doubt, the Aero feels every inch a SAAB. That means the driving experience is communicative and very enjoyable. SAAB has stiffened both the chassis and suspension up on all 9-5 in the revision process. The steering provides excellent road feel. Considered this is a high-powered front-driver, both understeer and torque steer are issues but remain very controllable. The suspension handles corners in a manner that’s more forgiving than previous 9-5s I have driven. However, body rolls remain an issue. For 2002, ESP has been added to the already safe package. The system feels more instrusive than I expected. I can forgive this design considered how much hp SAAB put the chassis through the front wheels. The ride is comfortable and firm.

Brakes: As with SAAB’s tradition, the pedal feel is excellent. Its an almost flawless system.

Interior: The aeroplane-inspired concept is just a joy to sit inside. The fit-and-finish is top-notch. Every panels are covered in plastic that has an expensive feel. Both the radio and climate control placed in a location that falls right into the driver’s hand. Instrumentation gauges are clear and analog. The leather-covered seats are probably the most comfortable seats I have ever sat in. The back seats are spacious, the design makes it feel like a living room sofa. The ventliation seats feature is nifty. You feel like the leather is breathing on your body as you turned it on. The trunk is huge, it also gets the uninstrusive trunk hingles.

Conclusion: If the original 9-5 already the best SAAB ever, SAAB just makes the best even better. Great powerplant, great interior, very good handling judging on how much power put through the front wheels and added ESP. Best of all, it still feels and drives like anything but a SAAB. Its a mistake of not put a 9-5 in your shopping list if you are cross shopping A6 and 5-Series in the price range.

OVERALL RATINGS FOR 2002 SAAB 9-5 Aero
================================
Performance: 5/5
Handling/fun-to-drive: 4/5
Fit-and-finish/built quality: 5/5
Interior/spaciousness/user-friendliness: 5/5
Value-for-money: 3.75/5

Overall rating: 4.5/5