Currently browsing category

LaCrosse/Allure

2012 Buick LaCrosse e-Assist

Vehicle: 2012 Buick LaCrosse e-Assist with Convenience Group and power moonroof
Price as tested: CDN$41750

Performance: While the uplevel 3.6 liter has uprated to 303hp, its the e-Assist which is the highlight of LaCrosse’s changes. The e-Assist is basically a set of lithium-ion batteries located at the back of the trunk, which uses regenerative braking to power all the necessary power items. Another benefit is the e-Assist uses the extra energy on top of the 2.4 liter Ecotec 16-valve engine’s performance and efficiency, for those who don’t need to upgrade to the V6. In real life driving, we won’t noticed anything during the transition between e-Assist and gasoline engine. Its as seamless as any gasoline engine out there, with the benefit of exceptional fuel economy. Another credit is where GM is honest about their energy rating. With the 4-cylinder combined with the batteries. The LaCrosse has 182hp and 172 lb/ft of torque. The e-Assist alone cost 15hp and 79 lb/ft of torque. For many carmakers, especially those who hybrid driven, they would cooked their figures for better marketing purpose. For GM, its all about fact. That said, the Ecotec has benefitted from direct fuel injection, variable valve timing and electronic throttle as a host while adding the sweet 6-speed automatic to the mix. All of these have combined to make LaCrosse to achieve such an excellent fuel economy for such a heavy 3775kg of luxury ride. We are able to combined 7.3 liters per 100km, as a combined figure. That’s dare close to Buick’s posted 7 liters per 100km. Without the proper gear ratios of GM’s wonderful 6-speed automatic, we won’t be able to achieve such a nice numbers. This is a rarity with anything gas and batteries combined, which is usually pretty far off to a complete disappointment. The engine start/stop system wraps up e-Assist’s economical equation, which turns the engine off while keeping all the power accessories working while stuck in traffic on in short traffic light stops. As a whole package, e-Assist impressed. :D

Handling: While everyone would have lamented LaCrosse as a traditional Buick luxury sedan, which put more emphasis on luxury over dynamics. The LaCrosse continues to be impressed. Along with the Epsilon 2 architecture, which has been famous for its world-class rigidty and stiffness. It has served as a great foundation for suspension to hang its hats. That means it provides the equally compelling ride quality as one expects from a Buick, without losing anything when it comes to handling. In fact, LaCrosse handles as good as anything else from Japan and Europe at its pricepoint. The suspension is soft without feeling like a wet noodle, while adding a sense of suppleness and firmness to add to driver’s confidence. The result is a full-lined luxury sedan which is as capable in any corners as on the open highway. The steering provides progressive feel and feedback even though it feels a bit vague, off-center. Its not too hard to induce understeer when pushed into limits. While you certainly won’t mistaken a LaCrosse as a Porsche Panamera on black-top twisties, the amount of confidence and inspiring dynamics would certainly delight many of those naysayers who won’t believe a Buick full-sizer is actually a capable car. Whenever a driver rears the ugly heads, there is always GM’s Stabiliztrak waiting in the wings to control under and oversteer.

Brakes: Hybrids used to feel spongy with regenerative braking. With LaCrosse’s e-Assist, it doesn’t feel anything numb or spongy at all. In fact, the pedal always feels firm and solid even when nailed the pedal to the metal. The stopping distance is short, while pedal feels confidence-inspiring. An ABS doesn’t have any annoying intervention basically has told how well-engineered LaCrosse as an entire package.

Interior: LaCrosse as a full-size luxury car, its rear head and legrooms are very impressive. It has limosine-like space for 2 adults while there are more than enough for 3 adults without feeling a bit of squeeze. The same goes for the huge luggage space. Even with the lithion-ion batteries eaten some of the luggage space, it still has a large 10.9 cubin feet of cargo space.

Up front, LaCrosse’s use of materials and fit-and-finish continue to be impressed. The interior appointment is world-class right from the initutive of the controls to how well the materials are put together. The use of a nice wood trim combined with classy plastic and leather materials have shown how far GM interior has come along in last few years.

Conclusion: The holy grail of e-Assist is the ability to get the posted fuel economy without having to pay the premium. Or the premium which have to justify for the hybrids for years down the road. All this technology has done to LaCrosse’s overall package is marvelous. It doesn’t upset anything good about the LaCrosse while provide the fuel economy and performance at a stylish package. Its a whole package for those who won’t need to upgrade to 303hp V6. Its like having a cake and eat it too. :D

Competitions:
Acura TL
Audi A4
BMW 3-Series
Lexus ES350
Infiniti G25
VW CC

OVERALL VERDICT FOR 2012 Buick LaCrosse e-Assist
=====================================
Performance: 4.5/5
Handling and ride/fun-to-drive: 4/5
Interior/ergonomics/user-friendliness: 5/5
Fit-and-finish/build quality: 5/5
Cargo/accessibility/layout: 5/5
Value-for-money: 4.5/5

Overall rating: 4.5/5

2010 Buick LaCrosse

Vehicle: 2010 Buick LaCrosse CXS with Touring Pkg and Driver Confidence Pkg
Price as tested: CDN$44590

Performance: Buick used to stand for boring and designed for those who have one of their legs in the grave. They decided to change all that with the introduction of the new LaCrosse. Does this car have enough credit to earn young customers, who never even considered Buick before? We will find out after this test drive.

The LaCrosse is powered 2 sets of directly injected V6 engines. On the base model, its powered by a 3.0 liter with 255hp and 217 lb/ft of torque, which is more than enough for daily driving. However, its the uplevel 3.6 liter V6 that is the engine of choice. Not only does it have direct fuel injection and variable valve timing to boost performance, this engine has plenty of refinement and quality engineering put through the whole process. Its as smooth, refined and quiet as anything else in LaCrosse’s segment. In terms of power, it got 280 ponies and 259 lb/ft of torque at driver’s right foot. While 25 more horses and 38 lb/ft of torque might not seem much differene, the seat-of-the-pants feel of larger engine is significant. This powertrain is able to move LaCrosse’s 4065 lb of American lined of luxury with authority. That’s especially true when it comes to fuel economy. All those credits of providing excellent performance and economy have to be GM’s 6-speed automatic gearbox. Not only its smooth as a nut, it got all the right gears with the proper ratios. The top 5th and 6th gears are tall enough to superb highway cruising while providing excellent fuel economy as overdrive. On the other hand, 1st and 2nd gears are short enough to peppy acceleration. Not to mention LaCrosse’s throttle tip-in is quick without being over-reactive.

Handling: It used to be when you talked about the word “Buick”, its an oxymoron to put driving dynamics altogether. The LaCrosse has to ability to change all that perception. Not only does LaCrosse’s suspension is comfortably compliant for some sporty driving experience, its also comfortable enough to cruise around. The Touring Package on our tester has Adaptive suspension, which adjusts to driver’s behaviour. This system really has desired effect, as it provides LaCrosse with right driving dynamics without losing the ride comfort once associates with driving a Buick. The steering is surprisingly sharp and responsive, without all those loose feel and feedback once with driving a Buick. There are body rolls and safe understeer. On the other hand, GM’s Stabiliztrak stability control has worked exceptionally well to prevent driver from rearing LaCrosse’s ugly heads in emergency situation. What really surprise me is how supple the ride with this new Allure. Unlike the unsettled soft ride quality with the Buick of old, this LaCrosse is finally a Buick that is able to ride along without driven with scare.

Brakes: With 4-wheel discs and standard ABS, the LaCrosse’s pedal feels solid and reassuring. It doesn’t have the annoying numb and dead feedback with all the Buicks have gone before. The stopping distance is short while brake feel is predictable and refined. ABS only kicks in necessarily without unwanted intervention.

Interior: While the previous LaCrosse has terrible ergonomics and poorly-finished interior, the new one is anything but.

The new Allure’s interior is exceptionally well laid out. All the center console and door panels are covered in high-quality plastic materials, which are soft to the touch. The workmanship is precise and world class. Instrumentation gauges are clear and analog. Everything else from the auto climate control and stereo are very well-placed. They are also user-friendly without needing to flip open an owner’s manual to figure it out. In terms of overall execution, this has to be the best interior Buick has ever made.

The leather seats are comfortable and well-foamed. With 8-way power adjustable seats and tilt/telescopic steering, its very easy to find a proper driving position for anything else at any size.

If there is a major drawback with the LaCrosse. Its the lack of a proper fold-down rear seats and the liftover of the trunk is high, that’s despite it uses uninstrusive trunk hinges rather than those poppy leavers that crash anything underneath.

Conclusion: If GM is able to convince younger audience into the Buick showroom, have them test drive the new LaCrosse. This car would certainly convince them to try to own a Buick. It got plenty of power, handles extremely well and ride comfortably. Best of all, it got a beautiful interior to match its exterior looks. For so many years, there is no direct rival to challenge Lexus’s venerable ES350. The new Buick LaCrosse has turned the table and become the real challenger, this car has accomplished of what it needs to do and so much more.

OVERALL VERDICT FOR 2010 Buick LaCrosse
=====================================
Performance: 4.5/5
Handling and ride/fun-to-drive: 4/5
Interior/ergonomics/user-friendliness: 5/5
Fit-and-finish/build quality: 5/5
Cargo/accessibility/layout: 2/5
Value-for-money: 4/5

Overall rating: 4/5

2008 Buick Allure

Vehicle: 2008 Buick Allure Super
Price as tested: CDN$38765

Performance: Unlike the standard Allure, the Super is powered by an OHV 16-valve 5.3 liter V8. This engine never fails to impress during take-off with its 323 lb/ft of torque. Drop the throttle and the Allure takes off with authority. When its time to push it through the rev range, 300 ponies are there when your right foot is ready. As with most American V8, throttle response is quick and brisk with a bit of over-sensitivity during initial throttle tip-in. While a sensitive throttle might be good for driving enthuisast, its target audience would feel jerky during launch. The only gearbox that matched with the Super is GM’s typical smooth shifting 4-speed automatic. The shifts are gear and linear with the ratios set for highway cruising. However, it would be much better if GM is willing to invest a 5 or 6-speed for the Super given the price its charging.

(more…)

OVERALL VERDICT FOR 2008 Buick Allure
=====================================
Performance: 4/5
Handling and ride/fun-to-drive: 2/5
Interior/ergonomics/user-friendliness: 2/5
Fit-and-finish/build quality: 3.5/5
Cargo/accessibility/layout: 4/5
Value-for-money: 3/5

Overall rating: 2.75/5