Vehicle: 2012 BMW 328i Sport Line with Steptronic, Executive Pkg and Premium Pkg
Price as tested: CDN$53770
Performance: In the last couple of years, BMW loves to mess up with perfectly good things or just plain coming out with answers that nobody has ever asked. Have they messed up with their bread-and-butter product, 3-Series, which accounts for more than 70% of their overall worldwide sales?
Beneath the controversial new grille lies 3 hearts of matters in this 6th generation of the 3-Series. For those who are seeking for low monthly lease payment and daily driving, the base 320i with 185hp is more than adequate. If you are looking for pure performance, 335i with 306hp N55 straight-6 is the real deal. However, most consumers would go for the 328i. While it shares the same N20 4-cylinder turbocharged engine with base 320i, it has 245hp and, more importantly, 255 lb/ft of torque, at driver’s right foot. Along with all the advanced technologies right from BMW’s variable valve timing called Double VANOS, direct fuel injection, electronic throttle, 16-valves and low-pressure turbo; it remains to have some annoying turbo lag at around 1200-1300rpm. What makes this application different than the one we tested in Z4, 5-Series and X1; however, is the N20 relies in the 3-Series is a far smoother and refined operator at all rpm. In terms of engine smoothness and refinement, BMW’s legendary straight-6′s turbine-line delivery is a work-of-art as we have seen in their glorious days in E46 330i ZHP. With the new 3, you can have a smooth 6-speed manual with a nice and progressive clutch. Or the no-cost 8-speed Steptronic with paddle shifters in our tester. The shifts are crisp, smooth, well-defined with perfectly fined ratio to match N20′s personality. Paddle shifters are able to overide at any given gears have shown its a nicely engineered piece. Even with 3461lb, the performance delivered by N20 is already more than we asked for. Then here lies the rough……….
The N20′s engine note is neither memorable or forgettable, at least its not noisy and rough as we have witnessed in X1. You won’t have the same entertaining straight-6 engine note as we are so unforgettable in their glorious days. Another problem is this 245hp has to drink Premium 92 or above octane, when you have to think of this. Hyundai’s world beating 274hp 2.0T in Sonata is able to drink Regular 87 octane. The “Eco Pro” mode, which is able to improve the fuel economy by up to 20% according to BMW. While its able to adjust the shift points and throttle position to achieve the desired fuel economy, if you drive it accordingly. This unnecessary feature actually makes fuel economy worse, as driver usually push it even more as throttle should be controlled by driver instead of computer.
Handling: While there have never been anyone would doubt BMW for engineered a world-class rear-drive chassis with ideal 50/50 weight distribution, well-calibrated suspension, excellent damping and state-of-the-art stability control. Speaking of damping characteristics, there is an adjustable dampers which come with the F30 3-Series. With a choice between “Sport” and “Sport Plus” as adjustabel dampers, latter really transforms a decent sports sedan into one which is capable of eating up track asphalt even when your adranline calls upon. Unfortunately. How many of those sniff*typical*sniff 3-Series buyers would use “Sport Plus” dampers which tigthened up the both suspension, shocks, steering weight and sports seat are beyond my knowledge. “Sport”, on the other hand, would most likey seen being used as its compliant and supple enough when its time to hit those black top twisties on a sunny weekend drive. There is one move which is very much controversial, in its own dynamic strategy. The change from traditional rack-and-pinion to electro-mechanical steering is very much debateable, as the set-up from 5 to 7-Series are just simply numbness nitemares. One of the hallmaks for 3-Series’s well-honed dynamics is steering feel and feedback. Their well-tuned steering feel and weight are damn perfect in E36; although E90′s poorly engineered, yet poorly executed active steering is something that change steering ratio at the wrong place at the wrong time. This move to electro-mechanical steering have lost some of the hallmark steering feel through its transition. While it remains precise and track the path relatively well, F30 never have the exquisite one-with-the-road feedback as E36 and E46. But its not as unncessarily, stiffy heavy as E90′s standard steering rackage. You have to give credit where credit is due. The rest of the dynamic package is pretty darn good. Rear-wheel drive balance with 50/50 perfect weight distribution certainly help the course. The handling and ride compromise remains nicely balanced, even with the ride on run-flat tires. Those RFT manages to provide comfortable ride quality without losing any of 3-Series’s usual composure. Body rolls are minimal. With our Sport Line’s sports suspension, it remains absolutely compliant and supple when pushed. On the other hand, the ride quality haven’t lost anything with stiffer suspension and larger wheels. If you would like to have a more luxurious ride, Luxury and Modern Lines are more your cup of tea than Sport Line. Wrap up the whole equation is BMW’s uninstrusive dynamic stability control. The incoming X-Drive AWD would be godsent in harsh Canadian winter climate.
Brakes: With large 4-wheel discs and standard ABS, 3-Series’s braking prowess is up to its sleeve. The stopping distance is short, while pedal always feels solid and well-modulated. The pedal never felt spongy after couple of harsh stops, while ABS only steps in at the right time at the right place.
Interior: In terms of luggage space, 3-Series scores with a low lifover and minimal side sills for maximum capacity. Because of corner cutting, BMW has changed the decklit hinges from uninstrusive to those instrusive ones. But given 3-Series’s price tag, its well-padded with near minimal instrusions for god’s sake.
There is finally a 3-Series backseat for rear passengers have legs and head. You have the same cheap door panels as the front, while the center armrest’s flimsy cupholders are just ready to break. With that mickey mouse button and cheap plastic opening, just a matter of time before it breaks. Why don’t they just leave 2 exposed rear cupholders instead of that stupidly designed cover?
The previous iteration of 3-Series, internally known as E90 in sedan form, already acknowledged for its significant internal cheapness versus its E46 predecessor. F30 has taken it a notch lower, when it comes to interior quality. No matter how many so-called “Lines” BMW wants us to swallow with different interior trimmings, which is a carbon copy of Mercedes’s Classic/Elegance/Avantgarde strategy. Its still unable to hide the amount of cost cuttings in the first place.
As usual, credit has to give credit where credit is due. The instrumentation gauges are typical BMW, which is both clear and analog. Auto climate control is effective and initutive. Well-foamed leather sports seats in our Sport Line provide awesome thigh and back support, when its time to push 3-Series through liberties. Driving position is easily adjusted and spot-on, thanks to multi-adjustable power seats and tilt/telescopic steering wheel. Their latest i-Drive is finally more user-friendly. But not exactly most user-friendly, mind you. The rest of the interior is mix blessings…….
Our Sport Line’s red trim line across the dashboard has spoken for tacky and pure cheapness. I wouldn’t expect this kind of cheap detail in a 53k BMW, which is something I would expect to see in a 19k Scion. While Modern Line’s wood trim looks expensive, it gives faux wood a poor reputation which is actually a “real” wood. Same goes for Luxury Line’s glossy, yet another poorly detailed wood panel. Then we come down to piss poor plastic quality, there are aplentry of those from the door panes to center console. The switchgears on the climate control, headlight switch and power window have lost those tactical, high-quality material feel we expect from a BMW. The multi-media display, which placed on top of the dashboard, tends to wash out during sunlight. BMW’s latest automatic gearlever design is far from initutive. You have to press a button for “P”, pull up for “reverse” while moving down the gearlever in not so elegant manner. Gone is the good ole’gated design with well-executed detents. Last but not least, BMW’s annoying electronic turn signal with poor detents remain intact. Although E90 is all wrapped up with nasty, cheap-looking black plastic; at least it has some tactical quality to behold on. In F30, its not.
Conclusion: What a relieve after driven the new 3-Series. Despite of my criticisms, BMW haven’t messed up with a car which they built their reputation on. Not only it retains a nice choices of powertrains, handles relatively well with more standard features; it finally got the space which it has been cried out for long time ago. Most of all, it hasn’t lost its dynamic charm which has made this car famous in the first place. But then there is a huge question marks……
When its rivals innovated turbocharged 4-cylinder technology much earlier than you do, while BMW has always been known for producing world-beating straight-6 normally aspirated engines for ages combined with rear-drive balance…..added edgy handling to the mix….those have lost during the transition to a 3-Series which feels more like a comfortable luxury sedan than an all-out no-compromise sports sedan as its forebears did. All of a sudden, this Bavarian carmaker have lost the magic touch it once was.
By all means, costing over $50k for a decently equipped 245hp 2.0 liter turbocharged 3-Series only leaves for those who have lots of disposable income.
Long lives the E30, E36 and E46.
Competitions:
Audi A4
Buick Regal GS
Cadillac ATS
Mercedes C-Class
VW Golf R
Volvo S60
OVERALL VERDICT FOR 2012 BMW 328i Sport Line
=====================================
Performance: 4/5
Handling and ride/fun-to-drive: 4/5
Interior/ergonomics/user-friendliness: 4/5
Fit-and-finish/build quality: 2.5/5
Cargo/accessibility/layout: 4/5
Value-for-money: 3/5
Overall rating: 4/5